While clearing down my info emails this morning there was an entry on the daily slashdot digest about Dell’s new advice to people torn between using Windows or Ubuntu on their computers. Like everyone else I suspect, I was expecting a checklist which helped differentiate the two operating systems and guide their customers to the right choice for them. Instead, it came down to - if you program or don’t fancy Windows, use Ubuntu, otherwise use Windows.
My take? I did a trial with my family four or five years ago to see if they missed Windows. For about a year they had Fedora inflicted on them and to be honest I don’t think they really noticed. They used Openoffice instead of MS Office, Evolution and Thunderbird instead of Outlook or, er, Thunderbird for email, and Firefox instead of, well, Firefox. For those irritatingly proprietary websites we even had Internet Explorer running under Wine.
Today, my main business machine is now running Ubuntu and probably 75% of my work is still done under Linux – its very fast, reliable and has a very slick user interface almost on a par with a Mac but not quite, and some distance ahead of Windows. For technical work, like the mapping, its streets ahead, and even for a lot mundane stuff like editing pictures and playing music its at least as good. And its simple “app store” model for just about very application type you can think of makes it so easy to find, install, and update applications (for free of course!).
My son has a netbook and he loves Ubuntu NBR – its quicker and easier to use than Windows on such small computers (screen and processor). And it seems he’s far from alone as Linux on netbooks has become mainstream.
So why do we still have a Windows computer as well? For two reasons:
- Openoffice seems to have made no real progress in recent years while MS Office has been revolutionised since their 2007 version. The Oo interface is a ’90′s throwback – I’ll be the first to admit is probably got more features but you have to go searching for them and frankly I just want write reports not study word processing. Why is it taking so long? The OpenOffice Renaissance project seems to have been under-way for ages now; in the mean time Oo stands-out on my desktop like a sore thumb against all the other applications I use.
- Secondly, schools seem obsessed by Microsoft. If we didn’t have a Windows computer its not clear my kids would be able to finish their homework.
So hats off to Microsoft - Windows 7 is a huge improvement and Office 2010 is great – for lots of people Windows is just right for them. If OpenOffice could get their collective heads around just how far their interface has fallen behind, then those same people could equally be using Linux, and schools might be able to save a pile of money. In the mean time Ubuntu will very comfortably dominate a growing number of niches, like netbooks and high-end workstations.
Still not sure? If you have some spare disk-space then try WUBI – “Windows Ubuntu Installer”. It installs Ubuntu under Windows and if you don’t like it, just remove it like any other application. But if you do, you have a dual-booting machine which is able to run both without formatting disks and all the messy stuff associated with installing a new operating system. Well worth a try.